- We ship on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday
Lucille’s Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookie is a thick, bakery-style peanut butter cookie baked fresh in Scottsdale, Arizona. Made from scratch with crunchy peanut butter, real butter, roasted peanuts, brown sugar, and pure vanilla extract, this cookie delivers bold peanut flavor with a perfectly balanced sweet-and-salty finish.
If you’re searching for homemade peanut butter cookies in Scottsdale, gourmet peanut butter cookies in Arizona, or fresh baked cookies for corporate events, dessert trays, or gift boxes, this is one of Lucille’s Baked Goods’ signature best sellers. Each cookie is baked in small batches for maximum flavor and freshness.
We offer local Scottsdale delivery and nationwide shipping, so you can enjoy handcrafted peanut butter cookies wherever you are.
This is peanut butter turned all the way up.
Lucille’s Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookie doesn’t hide behind chocolate. It doesn’t play it safe. It leans into that rich, roasted peanut flavor from the very first bite.
Crunchy peanut butter gives it texture. Salted roasted peanuts add depth and just enough bite. The edges bake golden with a slight crisp, while the center stays thick, soft, and satisfying.
It’s nostalgic — like the peanut butter cookies you grew up with.
But bigger. Bolder. Better.
This is the cookie peanut butter lovers order on purpose.
No frills. No frosting. Just pure peanut power.
Life is better when you eat a cookie…
Make it count. Make it Lucille’s.
Ingredients: White flour, crunchy peanut butter, unsalted butter, light brown sugar, granulated sugar, salted dry roasted peanuts, eggs, vanilla extract, salt, baking powder, baking soda.
Contains: Wheat, peanuts, milk, eggs.
