- Click Here For 10% OFF Your First Order
Peanut butter turned all the way up.
Rich, nutty flavor with a crisp edge and a dense, satisfying bite.
This is the one peanut butter lovers come back for.
Lucille’s Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookie is a thick, bakery-style peanut butter cookie baked fresh in Scottsdale, Arizona.
Made from scratch with crunchy peanut butter, roasted peanuts, real butter, and brown sugar, this cookie delivers deep, bold peanut flavor with a perfectly balanced sweet-and-salty finish.
If you’re searching for peanut butter cookies in Scottsdale, gourmet peanut butter cookies in Arizona, or fresh baked cookies for gift boxes, corporate events, or everyday indulgence, this is one of Lucille’s Baked Goods’ signature best sellers.
Each cookie is baked in small batches for maximum flavor, texture, and freshness.
This is peanut butter turned all the way up.
Lucille’s Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookie is thick, rich, and unapologetically nutty. From the first bite, you get bold roasted peanut flavor layered with buttery sweetness and just the right touch of salt.
The edges bake golden with a slight crisp, while the center stays soft and dense—the kind of cookie that feels substantial in your hand. Crunchy peanut butter and salted peanuts work together to give you texture in every bite, so it’s never flat, never boring.
It’s classic. It’s nostalgic. It’s powerful.
This is the cookie peanut butter lovers search for.
The one that doesn’t hide behind chocolate.
The one that lets the peanut flavor shine.
Simple ingredients. Big flavor. No apologies.
Life Is Better When You Eat a Cookie… Make It Count. Make It Lucille’s.
Made with crunchy peanut butter + roasted peanuts
Bold, rich peanut flavor in every bite
Crisp edges with a soft, dense center
Perfect balance of sweet and salty
Thick, bakery-style cookie (3 oz)
Individually wrapped for freshness
Ships nationwide + local delivery available
Butter, sugar, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla, flour, baking soda, salt, crunchy peanut butter, roasted peanuts
Peanut butter lovers, gifting, corporate boxes, dessert trays, and everyday indulgence
Q: How fresh are your cookies?
A: All cookies are baked fresh to order and individually wrapped to help maintain freshness during shipping or local delivery.
Q: How long do the cookies last?
A: Our cookies stay fresh for up to 7 days at room temperature and can be frozen for up to 3 months.
Q: Do you offer nationwide shipping?
A: Yes, we ship our cookies nationwide so you can enjoy Lucille’s Baked Goods anywhere in the U.S.
Q: Are your cookies good for gifting?
A: Absolutely. Our cookies are individually wrapped and perfect for birthdays, thank-you gifts, corporate gifts, and special occasions.
Q: Are these cookies made with real peanut butter?
A: Yes, these cookies are made with real peanut butter and roasted peanuts for bold, authentic flavor and texture.
Price range: $30.00 through $160.00
